Syncthing vs Rclone

Syncthing provides real-time peer-to-peer sync, while Rclone handles batch cloud operations. Different approaches for different needs!

Quick comparison

Feature	Syncthing	Rclone
Sync Type	Real-time, continuous	Batch, on-demand
Architecture	Peer-to-peer	Client to cloud/server
Cloud Storage	❌ No	✅ 70+ providers
Setup Complexity	Medium (GUI)	Simple (CLI)
Conflict Resolution	✅ Automatic	⚠️ Manual/basic
Resource Usage	Higher (always running)	Lower (runs when needed)
Mobile Apps	✅ Yes	❌ No official

Key differences

Syncthing (always-on sync)

Continuous monitoring with instant file propagation
Peer-to-peer—no cloud middleman, your data stays private
GUI-based configuration with automatic conflict resolution
Runs constantly in background (1-5% CPU idle, 50-200MB RAM)

Rclone (on-demand operations)

Run when needed via commands or scheduled scripts
Cloud-focused with 70+ provider support
Command-line interface with encryption and mount capabilities
Zero resources when not running

When to use each tool

Scenario	Better Choice	Why
Keep phone/laptop/desktop in sync	Syncthing	Real-time, automatic
Daily cloud backup	Rclone	Direct cloud support
Development environment sync	Syncthing	Instant code changes
Cloud-to-cloud migration	Rclone	Native API support
Family photo sharing (local)	Syncthing	Auto-sync between devices

Performance Examples

Syncthing: File changed → 1-5 seconds → synced everywhere

# Concept: All devices connected peer-to-peer
Device A (Laptop): ~/Documents
Device B (Desktop): ~/Documents  
Device C (Phone): /sdcard/Documents
# Changes sync instantly between all!

Rclone: Run command → transfer → done

rclone sync /documents gdrive:Documents    # Manual or scheduled
0 2 * * * rclone sync /data remote:backup  # Cron job

Features & architecture

What Syncthing Does Better

Real-time sync: Uses inotify/FSEvents for instant detection
Privacy: Data never leaves your devices
Conflict handling: Automatic versioning when files clash
NAT traversal: Devices find each other anywhere

What Rclone Offers Instead

Cloud connectivity: Direct integration with 70+ providers
Flexibility: Mount, serve, sync, copy operations
Efficiency: Only runs when needed
Encryption: Built-in crypt for any backend

Decision matrix

Need real-time sync?
├─ Yes → SYNCTHING
└─ No
   ├─ Need cloud storage?
   │  ├─ Yes → RCLONE
   │  └─ No → Either works
   └─ Prefer GUI?
      ├─ Yes → SYNCTHING
      └─ No → RCLONE

Best practice: Use both! Syncthing for real-time sync between your devices, Rclone for nightly cloud backups. Example: rclone sync ~/Documents gdrive:backup --exclude ".stfolder/**"

Bottom line: Syncthing for instant peer-to-peer sync with privacy. Rclone for cloud operations and scheduled backups.

On this page